Why so much criticism of KIPP schools?

I have heard some discouraging words from educators who criticize KIPP for numerous reasons.  I read an article today “KIPP Schools: A Reform Triumph, or Disappointment?” which got me thinking about these criticisms again.  For the sake of transparency, I will admit that I am heavily biased towards KIPP. Prior to working at KIPP, I worked at one of the worst middle schools in Baltimore City, that had a negative school culture, no parent involvement, and unmotivated teachers. Walking into KIPP and finding excited teachers, excited students, and excited parents was refreshing. I found a culture of success with high expectations, for all key stakeholders. So when I read articles like is KIPP a triumph or disappointment, I initially get defensive.  The Knowledge is Power Program is a reform implemented to bridge the gaps in education for urban students throughout the country.

Many education reform critics site KIPP as a reform initiative that is not living up to standards. They say KIPP should have better college graduation rates given that there is a big focus for students to graduate college.  Critics say that only 33 percent of students that attended KIPP middle school graduated college to date.  I find it interesting that this statistic is connected back to KIPP when many of those students attend non-KIPP High schools.  I also find it interesting that the word “only” 33 percent graduated was used but compared to similar students nationwide just 8% are graduating college.  Given the disadvantaged youth that KIPP serves and the population of students, 33% is a reasonable number.  Whether the improvements are in small increments or large waves, improvement is always a positive. KIPP serves about 99 schools in 21 states across America, elementary, middle, and high schools.  

 I find it to be extremely disheartening for people to criticize a reform that is visibly empowering urban communities and students. The KIPP organization personal college graduation rate goal is 75%.  KIPP understand that the college rates needs to improve which is why the KIPP through College Program exist and more KIPP high schools are being considered. The talk of partnering with colleges and universities is also in conversation. 

http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,2067941,00.html